|
Under funding from the US Department of Education's National
Institute on Disability Rehabilitation Research (NIDRR), a Phase I research project
culminated in March of 1999 with a pilot study was to assess the effectiveness of the Web
Trek prototype for allowing independent access to the Internet for individuals with mental
retardation. The basic hypothesis was that the Web Trek system would be more effective
than existing Web browsers (e.g., Internet Explorer) at allowing users with mental
retardation to independently access the Web. The pilot study involved a comparison of the
Web Trek prototype to Internet Explorer 4.0, and included 12 subjects with an average IQ
score of 58.9. The sequence of tasks performed for data collection on each browser
was as follows:
1. Conduct a
Search
2. Save a Web
site to the Favorites List
3. Conduct a
second Search
4. Save a
second Web site to the Favorites List
5. Use the
Favorites List to retrieve the first saved Web site
6. Use the
Favorites List to retrieve the second saved Web site
Each of the above tasks was analyzed to document the steps required to perform the
task. Data was collected on the following
dependent variables: 1) the number of prompts
required for each step; 2) the number of errors made for each task, and; 3) whether or not
a task was completed. The results showed that when the
Web Trek browser was used by persons with mental retardation to access the Internet, they
were able to do so with significantly less assistance and with significantly fewer errors
(see Table 1 below) when performing the series of typical Internet access tasks. Test
subjects also indicated a very high level of satisfaction with their experiences using the
Internet during the study.
Table 1: Web Trek Phase I Research Results
Dependent Variable |
Web Trek Prototype |
Internet Explorer 4.0 |
Significance |
| Number of prompts required to complete all
tasks |
Mean = 5.7
SD = 4.3
|
Mean = 17.2
SD = 5.7
|
.001* |
| Number of errors made |
Mean = 1.3
SD = 1.2
|
Mean = 5.7
SD = 5.1
|
.006* |
| Tasks Completed |
Mean = 6.0
SD = 0.0
|
Mean = 5.5
SD = .8
|
.026* |
The results of Phase I provided
clear evidence that the Web Trek browser significantly enhanced independent access to the
Internet for individuals with mental retardation as well as provided observed recreational
benefit to test subjects while using the Internet. Together,
these results provided strong support for the need to continue research and development of
Web Trek to provide a fully functioning and easily available Internet access tool for
individuals with cognitive disabilities. Accordingly, the US Department of Education/NIDRR
approved Phase II funding of the Web Trek project, beginning on September 1, 1999.
Although this project will continue through August 31, 2001, AbleLink plans to make as
initial release of the Web Trek system in the Fall of 2000. Plans for this release
include initial versions of the Web Trek browser and email programs, and the availability
of the picture-based Visual Search Site.
Ongoing Phase II work will include extended field testing, software redevelopment
and consideration of additional options and features.
|